What Secular-archetype are you?
Know thy Type of Secularism.
Introduction
Secularism, particularly in a diverse nation like India, is a cornerstone of fostering equality and harmony across religious and linguistic communities. However, secularism manifests in various forms, from genuine commitment to constitutional ideals to superficial or biased approaches. This article outlines the key types of secularism—Indian Constitutional, linguistic, real, pseudo, fake, and anti-secular—and provides a self-test to evaluate your personal secularity, helping you reflect on your alignment with India’s pluralistic ethos.
Types of Secularism
1. Indian Constitutional Secularism
Definition: Enshrined in the Indian Constitution, this form ensures the state treats all religions impartially, promoting equality and harmony (Articles 14, 15, 25-28, Preamble). Unlike Western secularism’s strict separation of state and religion, it involves active state engagement to balance religious freedom with social justice.
State shall not Favour or promote One National-Religion/Language over Other Religions/ Languages.
Characteristics:
- Ensures equal respect for all religions, with freedom of practice (Article 25).
- Prohibits discrimination based on religion (Article 15).
- Allows state intervention to reform practices violating equality (e.g., Triple Talaq ban).
- Promotes fraternity and interfaith harmony.
Identification:
- Supports policies ensuring religious equality.
- Endorses state reforms for social justice without targeting communities.
- Aligns with constitutional values of non-discrimination and fraternity.
2. Linguistic Secularism
Definition: Advocates equal treatment of all languages in a multilingual society like India, ensuring no single language dominates public policy, education, or culture. It aligns with constitutional provisions (Articles 29, 343-351) protecting linguistic diversity.
Characteristics:
- Promotes access to education and administration in all languages.
- Opposes imposing one National language (e.g., Arabic, Hindi, Sanskrit, Tamizh, etc) over other minority local languages.
- Protects linguistic minorities’ rights, recognizing language’s link to identity.
- Examples: Recognition of 22 languages in the 8th Schedule; multilingual policies.
Identification:
- Advocates equal opportunities for all languages.
- Opposes linguistic imposition, respecting regional diversity.
- Supports Article 29’s protection of linguistic minorities.
3. Real Secular
Definition: Genuine commitment to treating all religious and linguistic communities equally, aligning with Indian Constitutional and linguistic secularism principles.
Characteristics:
- Consistently defends rights of all groups, regardless of size or influence.
- Supports impartial policies (e.g., uniform civil code, multilingual education).
- Actions align with rhetoric, showing no selective favoritism.
- Example: NGOs promoting interfaith and linguistic harmony without bias.
Identification:
- Consistently supports equality across communities.
- Aligns with constitutional and linguistic secular principles.
- Avoids selective outrage or bias in actions and statements.
4. Pseudo-Secular
Definition: Claims secularism but selectively supports certain religious or linguistic communities, often for political or social gain, deviating from constitutional or linguistic secularism.
Characteristics:
- Highlights issues of one group while ignoring others.
- Aligns with vote-bank politics or specific ideologies.
- Inconsistent in defending equality, ignoring Articles 15 or 29.
- Example: A party championing one religion or language’s rights but silent on others.
Identification:
- Shows bias in addressing issues across communities.
- Actions tied to political or social agendas.
- Contradicts constitutional or linguistic equality principles.
5. Fake Secular
Definition: Uses secularism as a façade to mask ulterior motives, such as advancing a specific religious or linguistic ideology, misaligning with constitutional or linguistic secularism.
Characteristics:
- Secularism limited to rhetoric or optics, not action.
- Uses secular language to favor one group subtly.
- Opportunistic, adopting secularism when convenient.
- Example: Media outlets claiming neutrality but promoting one religion or language.
Identification:
- Discrepancies between words and actions.
- Affiliations reveal bias toward specific groups.
- Ignores constitutional or linguistic equality principles.
6. Anti-Secular
Definition: Rejects secularism, advocating for one religion or language’s dominance, opposing constitutional and linguistic secularism principles.
Characteristics:
- Calls for one religion or language’s supremacy.
- Pushes theocratic or linguistically dominant policies.
- Promotes exclusion of other groups.
- Example: Groups demanding religious-based laws or mandatory use of one language.
Identification:
- Openly favors one religion or language.
- Proposes policies violating Articles 15 or 29.
- Uses divisive language against minorities or regional identities.
Self-Secularity Test
This self-test helps you evaluate your alignment with Indian secularism principles, considering both religious and linguistic dimensions. Answer honestly to assess whether your views reflect real, pseudo, fake, or anti-secular tendencies.
Instructions
- Answer each question on a scale of 1 to 5:
- 1 = Strongly Disagree
- 2 = Disagree
- 3 = Neutral
- 4 = Agree
- 5 = Strongly Agree
- Be honest to gain meaningful insight into your secularity.
Questions
- I believe the Govt/State should treat all religions equally without favoring any.
- I support equal opportunities for all languages in education and public life.
- I endorse reforms to religious practices that violate equality (e.g., gender discrimination).
- I oppose imposing one language (e.g., Hindi, Sanskrit, Tamizh..etc ) on non-speakers of that language.
- I consistently defend the rights of all religious and linguistic communities, regardless of their size.
- I support state intervention to protect minority rights (religious or linguistic) without bias.
- I avoid favoring one religion or language in my actions or statements.
- I support a uniform civil code applied equally to all communities.
- I oppose policies that prioritize one religion or language over others.
- I promote interfaith and linguistic harmony in my interactions.
Scoring
- Total Score: Add your scores (10-50).
- 40-50: Real Secular – You align with Indian Constitutional and linguistic secularism, consistently supporting equality and neutrality across religions and languages. Continue fostering inclusivity.
- 30-39: Pseudo-Secular Tendencies – You may support secularism selectively, possibly influenced by biases. Reflect on inconsistencies and strive for impartiality.
- 20-29: Fake Secular Tendencies – Your secularism may be superficial, masking biases or agendas. Reassess your motives to align with constitutional principles.
- 10-19: Anti-Secular Tendencies – You may favor one or more religions (Monotheism, Polystheism or Atheism..etc) or own language to spread at cost of others, expressing supriority & opposing equality. Consider embracing constitutional and linguistic secularism.
Reflection Tips
- Review Low Scores: Identify questions where you scored low. Are you biased toward certain communities? Why?
- Check Consistency: Do your actions match your beliefs in both religious and linguistic contexts?
- Engage with Diversity: Explore X posts, news, or community perspectives to challenge biases and broaden understanding.
Conclusion
Understanding secularism in India requires recognizing its constitutional and linguistic dimensions alongside other typologies. By evaluating your beliefs and actions through this self-test, you can assess your alignment with the principles of equality and impartiality enshrined in the Indian Constitution. Strive for real secularism by consistently supporting fairness across all religious and linguistic communities, contributing to India’s pluralistic ethos.
GRP_VCare2Dare 